There is something that I’ve never really understood.
Parents who make their children eat everything that is on their plates.
I just don’t get it.
When I a kid, my parents did this to me.
I had to everything on my plate. If I didn’t it was brought back up for breakfast the next day.
In fact, one time, I remember being made to sit in the garden until I’d finished every last scrap on my plate.
I used to quite like this one though because it meant I could throw what I didn’t want to eat into the hedge and my parents would be none the wiser!

Surely as a nation who is experiencing an apparent obesity crisis, making children clear their plates, is doing more harm and than good.
By forcing a child to effectively overeat, how will they learn when they’re full and that they’ve had enough if they’re just made to eat everything?
Yes, I encourage my children to eat well, but I don’t force them to eat when they’re not hungry or when they’ve had enough.
They’ve never been big eaters. For breakfast, R will usually ask for a bagel, but we don’t give her the whole bagel as she simply won’t eat it. We slice it in half, toast and butter it, then cut in half again so R has two halves of a half. Some days she’ll eat it all, other days she’ll just eat one half of a half (a quarter of the whole bagel).
M is the same. She either has one Weetabix, again she’d never eat two, or she has a small croissant or jam on toast. Like R, some days, M will eat it all, others she won’t.
Before they go to school, I always ask them if they want anything else to eat. Sometimes they’ll have a banana, other days an orange or some jelly, whereas some days they won’t have anything else.
When it comes to their packed lunches, M doesn’t really eat much of it. She’s never eaten all of her sandwiches. Usually just a bite or two, but instead she’ll eat the fruit we’ve put in or the yoghurt. R tends to eat most of her lunch.
When they come home from school, they’re never ravenous, and that tells me that what they have eaten was enough for them.
If I cook them a meal or if we go out somewhere for food, I let them eat however much or as little as they want. At the end of the day children just don’t have the mentality to starve themselves at this age. They both have good appetites, they like to snack throughout the day which is fine and I make sure they don’t overeat. I’m in no way feeding them chocolate and cake all day!
I’d love hear thoughts on this! Do you make your children eat everything on their plates?
23 Comments
Melanie
June 7, 2017 at 11:13 am
I was brought up to have to eat everything put in front of me (Mum always said there were children starving in the world and I was lucky to have it!) I was also given food when I was happy, treats when I was hurt or sad – the result, i’m a very large lady with real food issues !!! I certainly do not want the same for my boys – food is fuel, never a treat! If they are hurt they have a cwtch, never a treat! If they are sad, we have a chat, never a chocolate bar !!!
I never expect my boys to finish a meal, I do however expect them to try everything I have prepared for them, but they rarely completely finish a meal. I am certainly trying to teach them better food habits than myself.
Heather Keet
June 9, 2017 at 6:12 am
I agree clearing plates does more harm than good and leads to terrible eating habits later. I encourage small portions to stop food waste! #ThatFridayLinky
Sarah Howe
June 9, 2017 at 6:42 am
We don’t make her clear it as trying to teach her to listen to be tummy when full. Saying that if she’s hardly touched a meal we push her to eat the meat and veg. She wouldn’t get anything else otherwise. Thanks for hosting xx
keepmum
June 9, 2017 at 11:00 am
great post, great points.
i don’t make my children, i encourage them as i don’t think they eat very much/ enough but i don’t force them
#thatfridaylinky
Tracey
June 9, 2017 at 1:41 pm
I recently saw a article that said children that feed themselves are more healthy because they know when they are full and automatically stop eating whereas spoon fed children were more likely to be overweight because the parents don’t stop feeding them until their plate is empty which I suppose makes sense. I have always encouraged my children to finish their food just because I hate to see it being wasted but I wouldn’t force them!
Anthony
June 9, 2017 at 2:35 pm
Agree with a couple of the guys above, I don’t think anyone should force a child to eat anything however if the adult is in charge of diet and portion control and makes food an interesting thing, then there is no reason why a child shouldn’t clear a plate. In fact if my four year old doesn’t I might be concerned that she had lost her appetite for some reason.
Do I make her sit there until she is finished? No but I do ask her to try at least once or twice a meal time. At her age and development, if for a second she thinks there is something better to do she say’s she isn’t hungry, now we know through experience that isn’t the case so we positively reinforce the idea of eating a little more.
Finishing the food on the plate in some countries is a sign of respect, as is leaving a little in others so I’m not saying its that black or white. I’m saying it doesn’t hurt to try and encourage healthy eating habits early on as to avoid fussy eaters at a later age. Eating all your beans or broccoli isn’t going to cause obesity in a child. Feeding them high in sugar and fatty foods might.
kristin mccarthy
June 9, 2017 at 4:13 pm
I dont care if the girls dont eat everything- but if they refuse they better believe their only post dinner snack choices are cheese, fruits and veggies.
#thatfridaylinky
suz
June 9, 2017 at 4:35 pm
I think you’re doing the right thing. Teaching children to eat everything is setting them up for trouble later in life. And who is to say that your portion sizes are right for that child?
That said, if they haven’t eaten all their meal, then they don’t fill up with snacks in between.
#thatfridaylinky
Mama Grace
June 9, 2017 at 4:38 pm
I let her eat what she wants and trust that if she’s hungry she’ll eat. #ThatFridayLinky
Musings of a tired mummy…zzz…
June 9, 2017 at 5:17 pm
Sounds familiar. My parents always forced us to finish everything. I don’t mind as long as they don’t make a fuss, that’s our rule! My parents now let my kids get away with murder when they go over there… #thatfridaylinky
Chloe
June 9, 2017 at 6:06 pm
Hi, I’m sure the girls will go up with a healthy association with their food as a result. And no food waste has to be a good thing #thatfridaylinky
Jo – Pickle and Poppet
June 9, 2017 at 9:17 pm
I was also made to clear my plate and the portion sizes got bigger as I got older and I put a lot of weight on, it took ages for that mentality to leave me and for me to leave food on my plate. For that reason I don’t make Reuben clear his plate. However, he will say he is full and then ask for something else to eat. He wants to leave his dinner and have something sweet. At this point I will tell him that if he is hungry still he needs to finish his dinner, if he is full it is fine to leave it but he wont be having something else to eat. I think it is important to encourage children to stop eating when they are full. #ThatFridayLinky
Lianne Freeman
June 10, 2017 at 6:30 am
I usually just let them tell me when they are full – obviously if they have only eaten a tiny bit I’ll tell them they have to eat more #thatfridaylinky
Amie
June 10, 2017 at 6:41 am
My partner is very pro plate clearing where as I’m the opposite. As adults if we have had enough we leave it, nobody forces us to eat it because we know when we’re full. Children are just the same #ThatFridayLinky
David
June 10, 2017 at 8:10 am
I agree, let them eat till they are satisfied. As a kid I, too, was forced to eat everything on my plate, which just caused resentment. If our two get hungry between meals they have fruit or rice cakes. If they aren’t hungry, they’re not hungry. You are right: they won’t starve themselves!
Great post.
#ThatFridayLinky
Finn
June 10, 2017 at 9:15 am
Totally agree that insiting on clean plates achieves nothing and can cause damage. I remember being forced to eat things both at school and at home that actually made me feel ill. No way I am doing that to my children. As long as they eat healthily and sufficient that’s fine. Why would you make them food that they know they don’t like or serve them more than they can eat? #ThatFridayLinky
jeremy@thirstydaddy
June 10, 2017 at 5:14 pm
we strongly encourage it, but I wouldn’t say make. The biggest issue for me is if she doesn’t finish her dinner and then expects snacks all night. Can’t have that
Jade – Raw Childhood
June 10, 2017 at 11:27 pm
We encourage them to eat their food but i wont make them eat it. It just means that they don’t get anything else after it. It’s important to remember that it isn’t what they eat over the day it’s what they eat over the week so unless they dont eat all week then i start to get a bit worried #thatfridaylinky
Sadie
June 12, 2017 at 10:35 am
We aren’t strict about the kids finishing what’s on their plates, but we do like to make sure they eat enough. So sometimes we’ll say “two/three/four more bites” when we know it’s laziness or vegetable-avoidance rather than being full! When it comes to snacks, the first offer is always fruit, to make sure they’re eating out of hunger rather than just looking for sweets.
#ThatFridayLinky
Mrs Mummy Harris
June 13, 2017 at 7:10 pm
Right now as Ben is only just starting on finger food we dont push too much, but im definitely an advocate for no dessert unless dinner is all eaten, however I dont abide this rule obviously hahaha!
Me and Hubby were really fussy eaters so we’re trying to be as relaxed as possible with food pressures which seems to be working as little man is a ganite! #thatfridaylinky
Catherine
June 13, 2017 at 9:09 pm
I agree with you. I was forced to eat every scrap as a child and i’ve had a screwed up relationship with food ever since! Good on you for setting your own rules. #thatfridaylinky
Autumn’s Mummy
June 15, 2017 at 11:13 pm
I don’t agree with it. I think it just creates anxiety if you’re too forceful with it, and it could potentially cause a child to end up with an eating disorder. #thatfridaylinky
Lewis Brown
March 11, 2018 at 7:23 pm
I’m a firm believer of only putting enough on a plate for your child to eat. I would never force food down. If he eats it all and asks for more then fine. But I wouldn’t pile it up and expect him to eat it. Nice read.